Busting the margin myth – small roasters tend to take a larger slice of the pie

  • Producer countries’ share of commercial retail coffee prices has barely budged in the last 20 years, even with prices declining
  • Meanwhile at the upper end of the specialty market, prices rose by more than 75% – to whose benefit?
  • Big roasters often run on thin margins balanced by scale, while boutique specialty firms mark up heavily to cover small-operation costs

FOR years, coffee’s giants have been cast as villains. Their dominance, critics argue, squeezes farmers, depresses quality, and cheapens a product whose cultural cachet has soared in the past two decades. 

Small specialty roasters, by contrast, have been lionised as ethical stewards: charging more, but paying more, and telling “origin stories” with pride. Yet recent research suggests that reality is not so straightforward. Big roasters, demonised as profiteers, may in fact run on thinner margins — and deliver better deals to consumers — than the boutique darlings of specialty.

A new study examined retail and green coffee price data over two decades and uncovered a stubborn fact: producer countries’ share of commercial retail coffee prices has stayed remarkably stable, increasing from 21% in 1997-2001 to 23.5% in 2015-2019. The widening retail prices paid by consumers, particularly in specialty markets, have not translated into proportionally higher farmgate earnings. Instead, downstream actors – traders, roasters, and retailers – continue to capture the bulk of the value.

This information is not new. The surprise lies in where the value actually sticks. Specialty, long marketed as “lifting all boats” with higher quality and traceability, still sees producers capture no more than commercial shares, and often less. The paper also highlights stark variability: in company-level data, farmers’ share ranged from as low as 10% to above 40%. Large industrial roasters, with slimmer operating margins but much larger scale, can afford to offer lower prices to consumers. 

Small specialty firms, by contrast, mark up heavily to cover higher marketing, small-batch processing, and the costs of differentiation. The result is that the consumer buying a bag of single-origin Ethiopia for $25 may be paying more to the roaster’s story than to the farmer’s pocket.

“The idea that farmers benefit more from specialty coffee reflects a kind of economic culture,” says Karl Wienhold, co-author of the study “Is the rising tide of specialty coffee lifting all boats?” and Researcher PhD Candidate at the University of Lisbon. 

“Farmers often do earn a bit more, which in contexts of poverty is seen as ‘better than nothing,’ or even as charity. There’s also a widespread assumption that more value added must mean more value captured – an implicit faith in efficient markets and economic meritocracy, or the idea that hard work pays off, you get what you deserve, and everyone deserves what they have.”

“But our findings suggest otherwise. While differentiated coffee does usually pay more, farmers’ share of the total tends to be smaller, with most of the extra value absorbed by traders and roasters. Outliers – a few farm owners selling status-symbol coffees – reinforce the illusion, but for most producers the gains remain limited.”

Fairness, pricing, and the consumer paradox

This challenges the common view that low supermarket prices reflect exploitation while high specialty tags signal fairness. 

In fact, lower prices do not necessarily mean farmers are being shortchanged; they may instead reflect economies of scale. Big roasters and traders hedge efficiently, manage logistics globally, and operate at volumes that keep per-unit costs low. Their margins are often thin – far slimmer than boutique peers, who must extract more per cup to survive.

“We conclude from our study’s results that the question of power to extract rent and capture surplus is more complex than firm size,” says Karl. 

“Firms that can use economies of scale, like more efficient machinery, may operate on thinner gross margins because their costs are lower, leaving more money on the table – whether for themselves to keep, to pay suppliers like farmers, or to hold down consumer prices. If their size comes with market concentration, they may also be able to use that position to push prices down and capture what economists call monopsony rents. But having power and actually using it are not the same.”

“Smaller firms, especially those roasting much of the high-end specialty coffee, have instead raised consumer prices sharply without matching increases in what they pay for green coffee. That reflects their own buying power and results in a surplus that can go to above-average profits or to covering inflated costs. So while the largest firms may hold more bargaining power over farmers in theory, in practice rent extraction appears more prominent in differentiated segments where size differences are smaller. The trend of consolidation and large firms moving into these segments supports this view.”

For consumers, the irony is acute. The much-maligned “industrial” bag on the supermarket shelf may deliver a fairer split of value than the specialty pouch in a minimalist café. As the study shows, even in markets where producers improve quality, most of the value added is absorbed downstream. And where quality premiums do exist, they are modest compared with the surging retail prices of the past decade.

This does not mean specialty is insincere. Many niche roasters genuinely invest in long-term relationships and pay premiums above the commodity “C” price. But those premiums are often drowned out by the costs of branding, scale inefficiencies, and consumer willingness to pay. 

The result is skewed value capture: high consumer prices, middling producer benefits, and relatively comfortable small-roaster margins – at least in good times.

How to better distribute value capture?

For the wider industry, the findings cut two ways. They underscore the persistence of inequity: producers remain at the mercy of volatile commodity cycles and cannot count on specialty to deliver transformative income. 

But they also suggest a re-evaluation of where efficiency lies. Big roasters, stripped of romance, may be more consumer-friendly than critics admit, and perhaps more “fair” in how thin their margins actually are.

The implications extend beyond economics. As climate change and geopolitical shocks make coffee supply more volatile, value-chain stability will matter as much as ethical narratives. Larger firms may be better equipped to weather volatility, finance stock, and maintain flows – but they will face pressure to prove that efficiency does not equal exploitation. This is what many will be up against when facing new waves of mandatory human rights and environmental due diligence.

For smaller roasters, the challenge will be to justify their mark-ups in ways that deliver real, measurable benefit to farmers, not just aesthetic satisfaction to drinkers. The “origin story” is starting to wear thin, and to raise questions of who owns it, who capitalises on it, and whether that is fair. “Farmwashing” – showcasing producers and staff without delivering real benefits – has become all too commonplace in the coffee industry.

“We’re working to better understand how farm stories – and whether farmers themselves control and tell them – affect their ability to capture more of the consumer value they create,” says Karl.

“Building on Edward Fischer’s work, we see intrinsic value, or consumer appreciation of provenance and human identity, as something embedded in the production process but alienated once the crop enters supply chains. That value is then reinfused downstream and monetised after the farmer is out of the picture. We wonder, and hope, that if farmers can define and claim the ‘story’ as their own, they may participate in the commodity chain as protagonists, rather than just providers of raw material.”

In the end, the study punctures a convenient myth. The villains and heroes of coffee are not so easily cast. Bigger does not always mean greedier, and smaller does not always mean fairer. The industry’s task is to confront that irony – and for consumers to decide what they are paying for.


Coffee Intelligence

Want to read more articles like this? Sign up for our newsletter here.

Recommended